Electronic Ear Muffs For Shooting | Why I Like Them
There has been some discussion on the open forum about electronic ear muffs for shooting. So I decided to dedicate a blog post for this subject – and your further comments, experiences, recommendations.
My first pair of shooting ear muffs many decades ago were simply “passive”. They worked. Did their job. However, my first pair of electronic ear muffs set a new standard of being “spoiled” in this regard!
All future shooting ear muff purchases have been the electronic variety.
What are electronic ear muffs?
Simply put, they enable you to hear what’s going on around you (as in conversation) while also providing hearing protection from the BOOM of a gun.
The way it works is fairly straight-forward too. Think of it in three parts. The muffs (ear cups), a microphone, and a speaker (inside the muffs). Well, there’s more – such as the electronic circuit board itself & battery, but the high level overview are those three things.
How Electronic Ear Muffs Work
The built-in microphone will pick up conversation and any ambient noises around you. A volume control dial will enable you to adjust and amplify how loud you hear the surrounding ambient noise as it’s amplified into the speakers within the ear muffs.
When you fire the gun, the electronics will “sense” the sudden dramatic rise in noise level (very fast reaction time). When it does, the speaker output inside the muffs is shut off.
The instant the “BOOM” has quieted, sound is turned back on – enabling ongoing conversation or simply hearing your surroundings.
It happens so fast, you don’t even notice it.
UPDATE: You may notice a slower reaction (“attack time”) with some cheaper units. As well as a slower turn-on (ramp up the volume) time after the shot.
There are more technical details within the basics of “how it works”. Such as the threshold at which the audio circuit shuts down (typically around 82 – 85 dB). The speed at which it clamps (shuts down and turns back on). How much hearing protection the ear muffs provide (rated in dB). Additional features such as Accessory input capability (like connecting external audio devices). Hearing in STEREO rather than MONO. The shape of the ear muffs (thin or otherwise). Comfort. Color & appearance. Brand reputation. Where it’s made.
How I Use My Electronic Ear Muffs
TARGET SHOOTING
Well, duh, that’s what they’re for, right? When Mrs.J and I target shoot together (or others whom we may shoot with), it sure is nice to be able and converse rather than constantly taking the ear muffs off and back on again.
Also, it’s just nice hearing what’s going on around you while you’re target shooting. Being aware of your surroundings at all times while shooting is very important!
If you’re at a shooting range, it’s particularly important to hear what’s going on, or commands given by an instructor, etc..
HUNTING
Remember when I said there’s a volume control? Well, some electronic ear muffs can really crank it up. You can hear way more than with just your human ears! So, while hunting you’re going to be much more aware of noises out there. It’s amazing the difference it makes in this way.
ON THE NIGHT STAND – JUST IN CASE
Though I’m not particularly concerned that I’ll ever need it like this, I do keep a pair in the location around the night stand next to the bed (along with my home defense gun). If there ever were to be a situation in the middle of the night, I wouldn’t want to blow out my ear drums inside the confines of the home.
WHILE ON THE TRACTOR
Spending hours on the tractor while brush hogging can get pretty boring (though the blades wacking the occasional hidden rock sure wakes you up!). I typically will connect my iPhone to the accessory input jacks and listen to a recorded podcast. It’s great… blocking out the noisy tractor while listening to something else. Multitasking the brain.
SNOWBLOWER DUTY
Not only do the electronic ear muffs keep your ears warm during the winter, you can listen to music (or whatever) if you have an accessory input. And that’s exactly what I do after each and every snowstorm while the snowblower chugs the snow.
The Best Features To Look For When Buying Electronic Ear Muffs
- Thin versus bulky. I like a thin muff design because it’s way easier while shooting a rifle (cheek against stock). Though a bulky ear muff may provide more hearing protection (dB), the newer thinner designs can be quite adequate (check the specs).
- The best feature in my opinion has been the audio input accessory jack.
- Stereo. I can’t stand “mono”. Being somewhat of an audiophile, it’s worth it. Additionally, the directionality that it provides is a huge benefit.
Which Electronic Ear Muffs Do I Have?
Okay, this is not necessarily an endorsement one way or the other. It’s just what I bought at the time. Today, they make lots of great muffs that will be just fine. With that said, here’s what I have…
My first pair (actually two pair) that I bought is a brand named “Caldwell”. They’re sort of bulky (not bad) and I have been happy enough with them since. No accessory input. But they are stereo (directional with two microphones – one on each side). I like that it has a small red LED when it’s turned on – as a reminder to shut them off when you’re done! Otherwise you’ll be replacing those batteries next time.
Later I purchased a thin pair of electronic ear muffs. Why? Because my Caldwell’s were making it somewhat difficult for me while shooting a rifle w/scope.
Based on great reviews (versus price point) I chose a pair of Howard Leight by Honeywell thin design. I just checked and it still has outstanding reviews and are the most popular electronic ear muff today. But you know what? I didn’t like them. Why? Because the amplification wasn’t good enough in my opinion – they didn’t get loud enough for comfortable conversation (maybe it’s my ears — actually that’s probably what it is).
I thought I had a bad pair, so sent them back for a replacement. But the replacement was the same. So I sent that back too and went on to something else. To this day I’m not sure what happened – but they are obviously very, very popular!
I spent some time deciding what to do next. Eventually I settled on the old saying “You get what you pay for”. Knowing that I would have these for the rest of my life, I figured I would shell out the bucks to get a really good pair. And it was back in the day when I had more disposable income ;)
I bought two pair of “PRO EARS” PRO TAC GOLD. (It’s literally these).
Wow, these are really nice. Super comfortable. But like I said, “cha-ching”. I do not regret having bought them. I love how they have two sets of volume knobs, one for each ear. There’s a circuit board in each muff. I enjoy using the dual audio accessory input accommodating stereo input signals. The “attack” time (on/off during shots) is the fastest on the market. And the best thing I like about them is the amount of audio amplification for conversation and ambient noise. Way more than others that I’ve used. It’s like having bionic ears.
It’s like anything – there’s something for every budget.
→ view all electronic ear muffs on amzn
Anyway, that’s the story. So lets hear from you about electronic ear muffs. Do you have them? What are your opinions?
[ Read: Hearing Protection | Gunshot Loudness ]
I use Pro Ear Predator Gold. I too have collected many types through out my life, but love the Pro Ear. They have worked great in competition and I too keep a set next to my bed, if something goes bump in the night. I have hearing loss from my younger days, when I didn’t know any better. These are important, if I’m going to keep what hearing I have left.
As my ear doctor told me, hearing loss is cumulative. The more loud noise the worse it gets. I kinda get a laugh from the lawyer’s commercial about bad ear plugs for soldiers. Maybe in basic or advanced training but I never knew a soldier in combat that used them. ALL of the Vietnam vets I know have hearing loss and tinnitus. It’s a bitch not hearing 10 to 15 percent of a movie or TV program. Remember, IT’S CUMULATIVE! ALWAYS WEAR HEARING PROTECTION WHEN EXPOSED TO LOUD NOISE. Not just shooting. Cutting the grass, using a chain saw, etc.
My DW say’s that I’m going deaf, at least I think that’s what she said ?
Good article Mr. Ken. I guess I’ll git me sum pretty soon.
On my wish list. And made in the USA!
My first set of electronic muffs were Caldwell also. Bought ’em probably 10+ years ago, delegating my passive muffs to loaner status. Mine were mono, not stereo, but not a drawback on the range. Still got them, but the foam cover on the microphone has disintegrated, so wind noise can aggravate a little. They now serve as loaners also.
Bought my first set of Walker Power muffs about three years ago. Love them. My first “stereo muffs”. Makes a big difference in the woods, or when prowling around outside at night. The amplification causes you to realize how much noise you are making yourself, helping you become stealthier.
Ordered a set of Walker Razor Slim electronic muffs last evening. Have all the features of my present muffs, plus having a slimmer profile, and these are being shipped with a attachable/removable 22 channel FRS/GMRS walkie talkie w/boom mic. Hoping this combination will solve the not having three hands problem trying to manipulate a weapon, a light, and still stay in communication with others during those times such things become necessary. We’ll see if these will fill the bill once they arrive.
I have tried different ear muffs and they all seem bulky to me and give me a headache. Not to mention hot. It gets quite hot in those here in Texas. Are they heavy? Even the “thin” ones? I have been using ear plugs but am worried that is not adequate protection. I am debating trying these out, but really don’t want to waste money.
This kinda sorta fits a little bit into this thread (not really, but it does go with gun stuff preparedness). I’ll repost the formula for “Ed’s Red” gun cleaning solvent. Been using it for years, works great, by far much cheaper than commercial gun solvents.
Buy one quart Dexron ATF (automatic transmission fluid), one quart #1 Kerosene, one quart odorless mineral spirits, one quart acetone. You now have the makings for one gallon of “Ed’s Red”.
Mix all these together in, preferably, a metal container. Or, like I do, take a glass kitchen measuring cup and measure up 2 ounces of each and mix together in a pint Mason jar for easier handling. Seal up the larger containers for later use. No matter how little, or how much you want to make up, it’s four equal parts.
Simple, effective, cheap. A gallon for the cost of a fraction of commercial offerings. For those worried about polymer frame pistol or plastic stocks, I’ve used it for years on both with no ill effect. I won’t make the same claim for lacquer finished wood stocks, mainly because I’ve never used it on my safe queens.
Thanks for the formula!
So… your “safe queens” get the good stuff ;)
Ken,
Not really. Sadly, my safe queens rarely get shot anymore, just an inspection, an oily patch through the bore and a wipe down of the metal ’bout once a year. Probably ought to sell ’em, but the their value keeps climbing. They might pay for my great grand kid’s college one day. (or confiscated and sent through a shredder if the dems ever get their way). Probably not in what’s left of my time here on earth, thankfully.
I agree, buy Howard Leight hear protection headsets. The price is good and it has an external radio input. Works great with a two-way radio so you can hear clearly, but others can hear your radio. You just run the 3 foot 3.5mm jack wire from the headset to you lapel mic output jack. However some radios use a 2.5mm input, so you will need to buy aftermarket where one end is 3.5mm and the other is 2.5mm. Howard Leight will also pair well with mid and high cut ballistic helmet without any problem.