Berkey: Black Filter Elements vs. White Ceramic

Last updated on January 27th, 2019

Berkey black vs. white filter elements

Do you have a Big Berkey water filter? Are you wondering about the difference between the White filter element and the Black filter element? Though the black filters are standard today, the white filters are still out there.

It was confusing because some of the Berkey water filter systems used to come with white ceramic filter elements while others came with “Black Berkey” purification elements.

You might be asking, “What’s the difference between them, and what should I get?”

Well I dug into a little research for you and found some details:

 

History Of White Ceramic & Black Berkey Filter Elements

A man named Henry Doulton of Britain developed ceramic filter technology back in 1827. Over the years the Doulton company improved their water filters to include not only bacteria removal but also self-sterilization.

Their “gravity filters” became popular and used by military, relief, and even missionaries in faraway lands lacking clean drinking water.

Note: A gravity filter is one whereby an upper reservoir of impure water is filtered into a lower reservoir through a filtration media. Gravity does the work as the water flows from the top reservoir through the media to the bottom reservoir.

During 1985 a company named “British Berkefeld” acquired the Doulton company and their “White” ceramic filter technology (technically called “Super Sterysyl Ceramic”) and began selling to the public.

British Berkefeld continues to sell their “White” (Super Sterysyl Ceramic) water filters today through a North American distribution partnership developed in 1998 with the US based company “New Millennium Concepts”.

New Millennium Concepts then expanded this filter technology into what is known today as the “Black Berkey” purification element. They also expanded their filter housing systems into what we currently know as the Berkey® Water Filter System(s).

Here’s more:

 

The Black Berkey Comparison With White Ceramic

Evidently (based on what I’ve read from the respective companies) the Black Berkey and the White (Super Sterasyl Ceramic) filter elements (also called “candles”) both are excellent water filters. Though the Black Berkey is superior.

One of the differences is the Black Berkey elements remove more chemicals including Lead, MTBE’s, and other heavy metals, as well as filtering out more bacteria and viruses.

Black Berkey

Berkey Black Berkey Purification Elements, Pack of 2

The Black Berkey has been tested by a number of independent laboratories.

Bacteria: 99.9999%
Viruses: 99.999%
(source)

(White) Super Sterysyl Ceramic

Doulton 7″ Super Sterasyl Ceramic Filter Candle, Pack of 2

The Ceramic shell of the Super Sterasyl element is an NSF Listed Component and is manufactured to meet NSF standards 42 & 53 for materials.

Bacteria: 99.99%
Viruses: No
(source)

Additionally, the Black Berkey elements will also filter out Chlorine to undetectable levels. The White ceramic filters will remove ~ 90% (still good!).

Lifespan of the Black Berkey (set of 2) is 6,000 gallons.
Lifespan of the White Super Sterasyl Ceramic (set of 2, 9″) is 1,200 gallons.

 
CONCLUSION
Over many years I have used both the White ceramic and Black Berkey filter elements. In fact I still have a spare set of White’s along with a set of Black Berkeys. I’ve never had a problem with either one.

I own a Big Berkey water filter system and a British Berkefeld. Have been using the Big Berkey every day for our drinking water for many years. Despite the fact that I have a well water system (actually it’s a dug well into a natural spring) and a whole-house filter to 1 micron, I still use the Berkey for even “better” water!

EVERY SINGLE PREPPER should have a quality countertop water filter designed for daily use. Water is THE MOST IMPORTANT consideration for general preparedness and we should not take it for granted that we will always have a safe clean source of water.

There are many good water filters out there. I may be somewhat biased having owned Big Berkey water filters for many years, however I stand by them as one of the best.

Big Berkey - 2 gallons
Big Berkey, 2 gallons

Read more: Travel Berkey, Specs
Read more: 5 Berkey Accessories





48 Comments

  1. Bogan 06/12/2017
    • Southernman 06/12/2017
    • Southernman 06/12/2017
      • Antique Collector 06/12/2017
    • Hildegard 07/26/2017
  2. Bob 06/12/2017
    • Lauren 06/12/2017
  3. Dennis 06/12/2017
    • BlackJack22 06/13/2017
  4. Dennis 06/12/2017
    • BlackJack22 06/13/2017
  5. Skibum 06/12/2017
    • Lauren 06/12/2017
      • NRP 06/12/2017
      • Skibum 06/12/2017
        • Lauren 06/12/2017
  6. North Woods 06/12/2017
    • Dennis 06/12/2017
  7. T in TX 06/12/2017
    • Ken Jorgustin 06/12/2017
    • Ken Jorgustin 06/12/2017
  8. NRP 06/12/2017
    • Shepherdess 06/12/2017
    • Beach'n 06/12/2017
      • NRP 06/12/2017
        • Beach'n 06/12/2017
          • Beach'n 06/13/2017
          • Dennis 06/13/2017
          • Beach'n 06/13/2017
    • Skibum 06/12/2017
      • NRP 06/13/2017
  9. Modern Throwback 06/12/2017
  10. aka 06/12/2017
  11. Antique Collector 06/12/2017
  12. Yosef 06/12/2017
  13. 21Bravo 06/12/2017
  14. lifelonglearner 06/12/2017
  15. T in TX 06/12/2017
    • Ken Jorgustin 06/12/2017
  16. kenny 06/12/2017
  17. Texasprepper 06/13/2017
    • NRP 06/13/2017
  18. TheGhostofBelleStarr 06/13/2017
  19. JustAskin 06/14/2017
    • Ken Jorgustin 06/14/2017
      • JustAskin 06/14/2017
  20. ThoRig 12/25/2017
  21. Germain 12/30/2017

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published