SURVIVAL KITCHEN

Pros – Cons of Freeze-Dried, Dehydrated, Canned, Grains, Legumes

pros-and-cons-of-food-storage

A pros and cons list of the various methods and types of food for deep pantry storage that you may consider in your overall diversified preparedness plan.

 

Freeze-Dried Food

Pros

Long shelf life.
Very lightweight.
Very low moisture.
Reconstitutes quickly.
Best way to dry meat items.
Excellent nutritional retainment.
Generally tastes better than dehydrated.
Individual meal choices ideal for backpack.
Retains original shape, texture, color after reconstitution.

Cons

Most expensive food storage option.
Most items require water to prepare.
Items are bulkier than if dehydrated.
If purchased in Mylar pouches, susceptible to puncture.

 

Read more: Dehydrated vs. Freeze Dried Foods

 

Dehydrated Food

Pros

Low moisture (not as dry as freeze dried).
Lightweight (not as light as freeze dried).
Long shelf life (not as long as freeze dried).
You can do it yourself with a home dehydrator.

Cons

Requires water to prepare.
Some items have poor visual appeal.
May lose some taste after reconstitution.
Some items take a long time to reconstitute.

 

Read more: Dehydrated Food Shelf Life

 

MRE (Meal Ready to Eat)

Pros

Convenient to use.
Familiar foods available.
Requires no water to prepare.
No mixing or blending required.
Simple to add in a backpack, kit.
Can be heated for hot meal by many methods.
MRE’s taste better these days than they used to.
Can be eaten right from pouch without preparation.

Cons

Not intended for long term consumption.
Taste of MREs considered less than ideal by some.
Lots of sodium (needed for long term viability).
Artificial additives added in many recipes.
Expensive considering actual food received.
Entrees alone will not supply adequate nutritional value.
Because of foil pouch, they are susceptible to puncture.
Can be heavy if larger quantities need to be transported.

 

Read more: MRE Meals for Food Storage & Survival Kit

 

Commercially Canned Food

Pros

Wide variety of canned foods.
Secure packaging – containment.
Lots of inexpensive choices.
Readily available at all grocery stores.
Moderate shelf life, generally 3-years – depending.
‘Real’ shelf life often much longer than posted without issues.

Cons

Heavier than dried foods.
Difficulty in freezing conditions.
May have lots of sodium (for shelf life).
Typically lots of preservatives, other additives.
Not as practical for on-the-go or carrying.
Exposure to water and humidity promotes rust.

 

Read more: Canned Food Groups for Preparedness

 

Home Canned Food

Pros

Long shelf life.
Lots of recipes.
No refrigeration required.
Something you can do yourself.
Tremendous options of what you may ‘can’.
Excellent method towards self sufficiency.

Cons

Time consuming process.
Initial cost of jars, lids.
Glass jars, heavy, breakable.

 

Read more: 12 Lifesaving Home Canning Rules

 

Emergency Food Bars

Pros

Low cost.
Calorie dense
About 1yr shelf life.
Compact – convenient.
Good for portability – small kit, quick calories.

Cons

Limited nutritional value.
Not everyone likes the taste.
Inadequate for prolonged use.
Not a satisfying substitute for a hot meal.

 

Read more: The Clif Bar – Great Energy Food Bar

 

Grains, Beans, Basic Commodities

Pros

Low cost.
Good nutritional value with variety.
The basic food staples – very important.
Very long storage life if stored properly.
Essential ingredients for sustaining life.
Many sprout-able seeds, grains, and beans increase nutritional value.

Cons

More time consuming to prepare.
Heavy weight – meant for storage, not portability.
Not generally appropriate for shorter term emergencies.
Time is required to adapt to basic commodity oriented diet.
Requires relatively large quantities of water and fuel to prepare.
For calories, a fairly large quantity must be consumed when eaten exclusively.

 

Read more: Calories Per Pound Of Rice, Beans, Wheat

 
SUMMARY
There is more to this… Within each category there are some food items that offer more “pros” then the others in their group.

For example rice. White rice is easy to prepare, can be combined with almost anything to make a delicious meal and is cheap, easy to store and has a great weight to calorie ratio. Powdered or flaked potatoes have a similar list of advantages.

Rice & Beans – A Survival Combination

Variety and diversification are important for a good overall food storage plan.

The partial list above should give you some ideas to consider.

 
You might check out what Bob has over at ReadyMadeResources. Not only does he carry a wide variety of supplies, but food kits too.

Here’s his Emergency Storage Foods page.

Similar Posts

Get notified when new comments are posted
Notify of
CHOOSE AN ALIAS NAME
Affirm you're human... not a Bot


[ Read: COMMENT POLICY ]
[ Visit: Open-Forum for Off-Topic-conversation ]
24 Comments
Sort by Oldest First
Sort by Newest First Sort by Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Excellent breakdown and solid reasons to have all the above.

I’m odd in that after years and years of military and foraging, growing up poor I eat for fuel and taste and such is secondary.

The guys n gals at work get me tickled at things like “oh I can’t eat that because of the texture”.

Don’t get me wrong I love me some ice cream but if you ain’t gonna eat the rest of that hard crumbling calorie bar or that dehydrated pork chop MRE toss it over cause I ain’t gonna waste it

Waste not want not,,,
Heard that from somebody once and it stuck,,,

Personally it comes down to economy,
Money is generally tight or non existant, so i do what i can with what i got, so canning, dehydrating, because i can do both fairly economically.

Not that i wouldn’t love to have a big stash of freeze dried goodies, but it has just never been a priority.

Commercially canned foods are a main stay in my “long term” stash, just because canned SPAM and corned beef are good sources of proteins and fats. Buckets of grains is next in line, and actually the largest group in my storage, it will last forever so figure its worth adding to every couple years.

IMHO being able to cook up some rustic biscuits or loaf of bread will be huge if anything does interrupt the status quo, or even tortillas, i can grow veggies, i can shoot a deer, but grains are almost impossible to grow here. Just too humid, and without netting the birds get it all before its ready.

Same with white rice, or any rice for that matter, i store a bunch of white rice because it will at some point be un available,

Its not if but when,

Tommyboy,

What type deer do you have on the island? Whitetail, fallow, native? Are they pretty plentiful? Just curious, not planning a hunting trip.

Dennis,
Axis deer, by the thousands

Many of us like to store white rice. It’s low cost and has lots of calories. I keep parboiled rice or as some say, converted.

Why? Because plain white rice is mostly just starch and lacking many nutrients. One particular nutrient it lacks is Thiamin, aka vitamin B1.

The lack of vitamin B1 causes a nasty disease called Beriberi. A serious condition if the heart and nervous system.

Eating meat, vegetables and fish can provide the vitamin B1, but in the long run, who knows about future availability.

Prefer ingredients to pre-prepared foods; and stack it and forget it for my LTS. JIC a quick meal is needed do have a few buckets of Auguson meals that were half-price at Walmart a while back, and a few boxes of Mountain House meals bought when on sale at Costco. Food bars are kept in vehicles.

Have stocked up on grains, potato flakes, and instant milk, mostly in #10 cans and pouches from LDS store. Wrists just don’t like moving heavy buckets anymore. Big bags of beans in the freezer waiting to be broken down into smaller vacuum-sealed bags. Have a few #10 cans of FD meat and peanut butter, and dehydrated fruit and veg. Wish I could afford more, and a freeze drier of my own is at the very bottom of my list. Oils are in the freezer and big bags of salt and sugar in metal garbage cans.

Like Tommyboy have focused LTS on what I would not be able to harvest from my own land and nearby. Thanks Ken, good article.

Lots of choices in food storage.

A home freeze dry unit is over budget for us so we do a lot of home canning. We can from our garden: carrots ,beans, squash, beets,peaches,plums, etc. We also can chicken,turkey,beef and pork. We really like turkey , a very low price food item.

We have a Nesco dehydrator and do potatoes,peppers,plums, apples, onions and carrots. We do freeze some items , but look at freezing as a short term, temporary storage solution because of a possible power failure situation. Store bought canned foods make up a large part of our storage inventory.

Of course having the space to put all the stuff is a concern.If you have a small house/apartment it can be a very challenging experience, but an opportunity to get creative .

I don’t can pork but do can a lot of ham. I usually buy a couple around xmas time and that will last well over a year. IMHO ham is a must with beans,pea soup ect. 1 pint will flavor a couple of pounds of beans or split peas,add a little garlic,onion,salt and pepper and I have a meal that will feed 2 people for a couple of days. Add cornbread and it just went to 3.

poorman….like to add small cubes or shreds of carrots and potatoes to these types of meals. Like the taste, and if needed, it too can stretch the number fed. Also, add some powdered mustard. Like the kick of that in it too.

I do the potatoes and carrots in the split pea soup. The powdered mustard I never tried

Poorman— have come to love powdered mustard. Theoretically it should be same as mustard in a bottle, but it seems quite different taste in cooking. Use it in a fair bit, and love it in those soups.

Poorman…other benefits than taste to using mustard

1)supposed to help build muscles/retain muscle ” plant-derived steroid (28-homobrassinolide [HB]) that promotes plant growth could stimulate protein synthesis and muscle growth.”

2)”Dietary plant oxysterol 28-homobrassinolide (28-HB) is a proven antihyperglycemic” ———etc etc–

My experience with MRE’s is they are high in carbs and low in substantial protein like meat. As I mentioned before the Wornick MRE’s are awful. If they cannot make mac and tomato taste good the rest must be worse. They added a spicy hot flavor. Could not even pin point what it was. If you have small children I would not even be sure they would eat them even if starving. Hard to say what starving people would eat. Mr. spoke about riding out as a guard on a garbage truck going to the dump while he was in Vietnam. Said the Vietnamese would take anything and everything. Remembers an old woman getting hit in the head by a piece of garbage. Blood was squirting out of her head but she never missed a beat. Just kept on grabbing. Difference is most of us Americans have never been that hungry. Rambling over ya’ll have a nice weekend and may we never need our preps………………

Some time back I did a cost analyst of freeze drying v dehydrating ,,as long as we have order and the system keeps on keeping on freeze drying has some value ,if you have grid power ,,

But things don’t look so good for FD off grid ,l believe a better choice is a solar powered freezer system and a grow house ,,

I have the resources to do either ,and have chose the later ,

As good as FD food is fresh is better ,a properly set up grow house can supply some or all the fresh produce you can eat year round ,sweet corn in January? yep ,tomatoes in March ? yep

the new LED grow lights in a solar system designed for winter use is doable ,in Antarctica fresh produce is grown year round ,

Think out of the box ,, I know of a young lady in alaska that grows fresh herbs year round in a insulated shipping can ,of course in the winter she uses grid ,3 hrs of daylight won’t cut it with solar ,

Some observations on freeze dryers now available ,1 cost is too high ,2 the capacity is too small when it’s needed the most ,
3 the oil base pump requires too much work ,and is too short lived ,4 in a SHTF it’s a boat anchor ,

,,,Just my thoughts from experience,
TEA AND CHOCOLATE

Would the cost of the unit not pay for itself in the long term? The longer shelf life of the items, the cost of buying FD food retail, etc.? If you chip away at it over the course of a few years, it seems to me the cost savings would be decent.

Hi All, I have read most of the comments, Much of what we prefer is what will drive us. I am opposite of some I can mostly pork… year round as it is available and $$ is available. i rotate it out. and i keep a few packages in the freezer.I prefer beef fresh/frozen as well, but dehydrated/oxy free glass jars is how I store the long term supply- which is limited.I have some beef jerky. Meats are our exsitence due to prescribed diet/health issues. In an emergency neither of us desire to be ill so are trying to plan for sustainable in the long run. My days of eating Venison and other wild meats are gone. The brain wasting disease is in our area( within 10 miles) and it is transmissible to other animals… via all bodily fluids..from breeding and grazing in an area where an infected animal has been…time of viable transmission limits is unknown, is thought the protein is transmissible for many decades.unless it is buried deep. ..TOO many unknowns… . It is a matter of time. before more cases turn up in the human populations.UNLESS a treatment is developed for it and an early test to determine if one has gotten the protein. Our plan is to add rabbits, and possibly turkeys this fall as we get infrastructure. Having the ability to feed each set of animals is a major concern..with only an estimated <3 acre grow. and part of that is too wet to plow…and desire is for that grow area /green house, hoophouse that will give us corn and squash in january and root crops in succession well past the first frosts. Carrots, beets, radishes, some turnips… greens only for the animals , it is our best way to consume those. While not as cold as Alaska , humidity, moisture and other concerns will dictate where our structure is located.. .interested to know about grow lights necessary – cost and life expectancy. and heating concerns. Our lowest temps were in the teens for a few days here., and there are green houses in all kinds of places, to find the one that we can afford to heat/light for optimal plant growth is our challenge.. MRE's Naw. not even. freeze dried, simply can not afford it now. given $$ would have gotten one a while back, Dehydrator.? yes!. want to do a solar one for summer. to augment the electric one we use now…Goal is lots of summer squash, zucchini, okra, roasted pepper, sweet peas,and string beans fresh from our own garden and secure in the smallest space possible. Dehydration does that. One pint of Okra = 4 meals. Corn dehydrated 1 qt packed is 30 ADA servings. Ground beef packed into 28 oz peanut butter jar…about 5 meals.for 2.( roughly fresh/ 3.5 lbs.) Beef into jerky strips.? can't remember haven't done lately but one quart jar will make a boatload of spiced soup. with qt.dehydrated mixed veggies… Mushrooms and onion are also on that… Read more »

Just Sayin’, the rabbits are a good idea but I would not recommend the turkey. They are a pain…they eat too much, they are sweet but stupid about everything, the breeding pair need to be kept apart or the male will maul the female, but then you need more than one of each for companionship in their separate pens….and they poop up s storm! I love eating turkey, but is easier to grow out poults each year and then harvest them all than keeping breeding birds. We have done both but I do not recommend it. And I just reiterated this fact to my darling spouse.

I would recommend ducks in place of turkey. They are better foragers, eat less feed that I have to provide, lay an egg every day once they start in March and continue until October, they are fairly quiet and get along well with other farm animals. I especially like the Ancona ducks, which we raise. My ducks come in to the lockup enclosure each night on their own with the chickens. Plus you have a reasonable amount of meat to eat when you harvest one. Eat all but one of the boys, keep the girls for layers. Just my opinion but thought I would pass the info along as we have been through it.

On turkeys.Thinking we will grow out every other year., several ….on the turkeys.. .possibly… and cook and can results. Poop is good fertilizer..can use it composted or as tea in fertilizer mix. Have someone local who has breeding pairs…may have to get the info and obtain some from her…already a couple weeks old….
Hubby does not want ducks.too much noise./ I don’t know anything about them, he has had them before as a young teen he had to maintain. ..He does not like duck eggs,he can tell them apart. .. think he likes their meat. if we can find some that are quiet…might try them.
talked about guinea pigs (and guinea hogs- which would take a long time to feed out..)… guinea pigs have poor temperature tolerance.about the size of a rabbit.., requiring controlled enviroment…could gather grass year round to feed them.(make hay during summer and have enough to over winter them.. next choice would be pigs. and they will be growers… again sustainability. we do not have very many scraps..another possibility is a feeder goat…might need to move it to another location part time. would be posssible.and would clean up the brush..rose bushes and sweetgum sprouts. even will eat kudzu.

I believe that having all your eggs in one basket is not a good idea. Keeping a combination of these different types of food storage protects you in the long run. Eating fresh is always healthier but the FD and dehydrated will come in handy if the crops are destroyed or cannot be planted. Having canned goods, including home canned, for eating quickly and quietly is also a benefit. The freezer and frig could also fail. Back up your backups.

Security in layers :)

I see the Good, Bad, & Ugly of just about all ways of preserving foods, and Yes I do us practically all methods except FD-ing my own, but I do purchase quite a bit, mainly when on-sale.

I do hear a lot of “well this don’t taste as good as that”, Wellllll if were talking SHTF/EOTWAWKI guess what, that 8 year old can of Lima Bean soup is going to taste mighty good. And if it’s a little low on Protein are ya going to turn it down? I would bet not.

BUT if you’re talking a properly maintained Deep Pantry, “Store what you eat, Eat what you store” than you’re going to be fairly well set; BUT don’t forget those MREs and a few dozen cases of DF Tacos, again, when the Deep Pantry gets really low, that ‘gunk’ is going to be mighty welcome.

PS; 800# of Beans, 500# of Red Wheat Berries, 500# of Rice, and all the rest of that 15 tons of food is going to need a LOT of TP…. HAHAHAHA, Come on, y-all knew I was going to say that LOLOL

PSS; Food management is one of the most challenging aspect of living the Lifestyle, and maintaining a balance throughout the years. Methods of storing as the article above, is a HUGE factor in that management.

PSSS; Don’t forget the Beer. is a GREAT source of nutrition. Honestly.

0ldhomesteader

“I have some thoughts about freeze drying . . . my understanding is that things don’t pencil out and the amount of work ,,, I know some folks love them , but after looking close I don’t think that it’s the way to go for SOME preppers ,especially off grid or post SHTF, I’m going back to heat dehydrators and freezers ,i feel both are more sustainable under a SHTF in the LONG RUN,both can be run on solar panels , and for a given watt hour produce more available food ,than a FD . . . your thoughts??”

Responding on this thread as it seems a continuation. It’s just me at the farm right now. Later I expect a couple more to move out here, and upwards of about a dozen family and friends should long-term disaster befall us. Would like to have a year’s worth of food tucked into LTS, JIC security is precarious or means of local production are disrupted.

Building up my supply of staples from LDS store. However, fruit, veg, meat, freeze-dried for LTS, is way too expensive to stockpile in those amounts. However, using a FDer to prep LTS food, by any metric, is far less expensive than purchasing #10 cans of FD food, running as they do from $20 to nearly $60 per can depending on the product.

Do agree that after SHTF, FDer probably would not get much use.

Anonymee
A freeze drier would be nice, just from the capability standpoint,
But in reality for myself at least not much of a cost saver as electricity is quite expensive in the islands.
Canning supplies and greenhouse are more practical, and dont have a lot of electronic or moving parts